🧩 Have wood puzzles for sale? Reach out and let's talk about your collection.
Add your email to our Secret Sale list.
Specializing in Pre-owned Puzzles Since 2010
Secret Sales Sign Up

“Valentine’s Day 2008” | Tidbit SOLD

~28 Total Pieces 5″ x 3″ 2008 How’s this for a cute Valentine’s Day puzzle? Two swans making a heart surrounded by a very colorful image. In excellent condition. This comes in a plain white box.

Lot of 4 (Unknown Cutters) SOLD

NOTE: This is part of our special “vintage puzzle” sale collection. This puzzle has not been assembled and we don’t know if it’s complete, but have been priced accordingly. Puzzle 1: Going to the Fire 177 pcs 10 7/8″ x 9 7/8″ Box says complete, our count matches what’s written on box. Very old box, … Continued

“Valentine’s Day 2007” | Tidbit

~28 Total Pieces 5″ x 3″ 2007 What a fun way for a couple of love frogs to celebrate Valentine’s Day, a very cute puzzle. This is a mini puzzle in a small white box that Stave sends out to customers. In excellent condition.

Lot of 3 (Unknown Cutters) SOLD

NOTE: This is part of our special “vintage puzzle” sale collection. This puzzle has not been assembled and we don’t know if it’s complete, but have been priced accordingly. Puzzle 1: Washington Accepting the Surrender of Lord Cornwall Sword at Yorktown 570 pcs 16 1/2″ x 25 1/4″ Our count matches what’s written on box. … Continued

“Valentine’s Day 2009” | Mini Troublemaker Style SOLD

~27 Total Pieces 5″ x 3 3/4″ 2009 This is a pretty rare puzzle, the first time we’ve come across it in fact. It’s a mini Troublemaker style puzzle with a Valentine theme. You have 2 solutions to figure out in order to solve this. Not as easy as it seems even though it’s under … Continued

Pumpkin Patch | Stave Teaser SOLD

~70 Total pcs ~8 1/2″x 4 1/2″ 2011 4 Swords *1 pc with small bite mark (Solution not shown.) This is a challenging, 2 solution (so double the fun!) Teaser that also has some cute 3D elements. This should keep you busy being puzzled for many hours! Appears to be retired from Stave’s site. (It … Continued

💐 Cape Code Mantle in the A.M. | Stave Traditional

~75 Total Pieces ~10 Silhouettes ~7 1/2 x 5 1/2″ 2006 A very cute Stave puzzle showing some brilliant color and detail. Some nicely designed corner edges too for a smaller puzzle. Artist: Jeremiah Stermer Excellent condition. No personal pieces.

Starry Night | Stave Traditional SOLD

~75 Total Pieces ~13 Silhouettes ~7″ x 5 1/2″ 2005 Here’s your chance to own a Stave of one of the world’s most famous paintings, and what a puzzle it makes! Despite the size, the coloring and swirls will keep you puzzling for longer than you expected! Artist: Vincent Van Gogh Excellent condition. No personal … Continued

“Lighthouse” | Tidbit SOLD

~30 Total Pieces 3″ x 5″ A gorgeous image of a lighthouse. Nice touch to have the top of the lighthouse pop out of the surrounding frame. In excellent condition. Box has a tiny amount of wear and has a small indentation on the lid that is about 1 1/2″ long.

“Blueberry Pie” | Mini Troublemaker Style SOLD

~31 Total Pieces 2009 Another rare find! This is the first time we have come across this mini Troublemaker style puzzle. It has 2 challenges revolving around a baking theme that will sure to build up your appetite by the time you are done! In excellent condition. Box has crease on lower portion of front … Continued